The Superannuation Debate Rages On

Lately in Australia, people were able to access their Super of up to $10,000 if suffering because of COVID19 layoffs. However, it seems that four in 10 Australians who withdrew from their super under the Federal Government’s Early Super Access Scheme actually saw no drop in their income at the time. In fact, as some were collecting stable Jobkeeper payments rather than being a part-time casual worker, collated data shows that 21% of these recipients had their overall earnings rise by more than 10%. (

Recipients of the second round of super withdrawals spent $3,618 more in the fortnight after receiving their funds, compared with the bank’s customers normal earnings.  The second round of super access also showed that they used this nest egg money to increase spending in a burst. And 64% of the spending was on discretionary items (non-essentials). (Source: de-identified AlphaBeta analytics)

These figures tell a story of people who were tired of being at break-even and just took an opportunity to get access to their funds and spend it. It also says, damn, those analytics firms really analyse every little detail of our bank accounts!

The Future of the Super Guarantee Scheme

Australia’s government is looking to put up the employee super from 9.25% to 12% in 2021, which seems good news for employees who took long breaks from work, however, there are a few arguments against this.

One, there has been stagnant wage growth for five years, and because employers only give modest pay rises at best in modest growth times, this increase will mean a rise in a company’s wages bill without that naturally flowing to the employee’s hands.

Another sad reality is that the taxation benefits of the whole Super scheme flows more to higher-income earners, as they can put in extra funds at only 15% tax in most cases and earn lower-taxed yields. Because the Federal Government is propping up these Superannuation tax concessions, the cost of this initiative is growing so much that it’s “expected to eventually exceed that of the entire age pension expenditure by about 2050”, according to the Retirement Income Review, a hefty tome compiled by Mike Callaghan. (

What about Accessing Your Super when Young?

As housing costs increase and owning a house in old age is a more independent and cheaper way to live, there are calls for making it easy to access superannuation for working young people today.

Does superannuation really matter to a young person?  Or should they be able to apply for that savings for a house deposit?

“Yes, someone should be able to access their super for a house deposit when 20-29, but if they’re 30, then they should start saving towards retirement by about then”.

– Student, 15

An interesting projection is shown in the graphic above, which is putting in 11% Super to the writer’s paltry fund over the next 20 years. It makes sense for those of us who are self-employed and had time out from the workforce to raise a child/children (and to go to University) to try to play catch-up. I feel this is a better option than putting our proverbial heads in the sand and then panicking at age 60 that there will not be enough to live on, especially with an ever-wavering age pension.

If you’d like to learn more about the financial independence mindset, then my ebook How to Control Your Financial Destiny (3.99) covers this, with more about overcoming financial blocks and trials to get ahead in the second book in the Know Your Finances series: Create Your New Life of Abundance.

The third book, Creative Ways with Money (2020) helps you ward off scams as you understand better how to earn more from side hustle income, save money in easy ways, and find lost bank accounts.

Hey, wait!Would you like a free, goal-oriented guide?

Before you go, get this free PDF!